Jonathan Paden ([info]jpaden) wrote,
@ 2008-06-15 12:55:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Bi-Polar
A thought hit me during our worship service this morning. I wonder if people see my church as bi-polar, or a split personality, and if that's disconcerting to them.

We are a more progressive church of Christ. We have a "blended" style of worship service -- we mix traditional things with contemporary things when we put together our worship assemblies. (For example, we have lots of crucifixes hanging around, but we still have the traditional communion table; we sing both traditional songs and contemporary songs.)

Today really stood out, because one of our more traditionally-minded members was speaking at communion, and said something that would have fit right in with a traditional church of Christ (referencing a very old interpretation of a particular Scripture passage), but then we turned right around and participated in something that involved a more modern/contemporary interpretation of the same passage of Scripture.

There have to be other "contemporary" churches of Christ out there that have this same thing going on, since churches of Christ are typically so heavily steeped in their tradition and older methods of interpreting Scripture. On the one hand, we have blended assemblies, utilizing thoughts and methods from both the traditional and contemporary, so that we can celebrate in our diversity and bring all people and things together under the One God.

But I have to wonder what kind of effect this split personality (of sorts) has on our regular church attenders, and if it is at all disconcerting or even detrimental to our church- and Christ-seeking guests.

Any thoughts from the blogosphere?



(Post a new comment)


[info]rickantioch.blogspot.com
2008-06-17 01:21 am UTC (link)
Really good questions. I've heard blended worship described as an opportunity to displease everyone. I prefer to think of it as an opportunity to "sing your songs" so to speak.

My experience with this kind of thing during several years in TX has been different than out here in CA. In Houston there are so many churches that if someone was even mildly irritated or uncomfortable or whatever as we began to incorporate more "contemporary" forms into a blended style, many complained and/or simply found a church with a flavor nearer their liking.

The same may be true in other churches out here, but our experience at Antioch has been that people may or may not complain, but they adjust, and the new or different forms become part of our own "blended" style. Even our folks who have been c of c folks for years and may have quite traditional roots (think Bible belt, 1950s), have embraced newer forms over time. My guess is that happens because relationships are trumping preferences... at least that's my hope. :-)

Out here, so many of our guests and new folks have so little previous church exposure that they wouldn't even understand a conversation about "traditional" vs "contemporary." Some comment about the lack of instruments, but most just talk about the warm feel and friendliness they experience.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]jpaden
2008-07-12 09:33 pm UTC (link)
Thanks for sharing your experiences with us!

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]danpaden
2008-06-28 03:16 am UTC (link)
For my congregation, I believe the real issue has more to do with our attitudes of worship with our hearts joining together to reflect God's worthiness to be the center of our worship activities. I am sure we all hope to find ways to bring all our congregation's members to move their focus from mechanics during worship to rejoicing that our members are expressing their praises to God with grateful hearts.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

All In The Attitude
[info]jpaden
2008-07-12 09:39 pm UTC (link)
I agree. If our attitudes are right, it won't matter if something happens that some don't like. As the worship leader, I of course try to implement ways to keep the people's focus on God and Christ, and not on how something happens (the mechanics).

What really bugs me is when other people take the stage and don't have any concept for that goal and how to keep people's focus in the right place. But that's a different topic.

But when people are focused on God, and the Spirit is moving, it usually doesn't matter if two things happen in contradiction to each other (as in the particular Sunday in question), because people just go with the flow, see the good, and have their minds focused on the One above.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…